Claiming credit for tax paid abroad
Foreign tax credit is the mechanism that stops a Pakistani resident with overseas income paying twice on the same money. It works, it is available, and it is claimed far less often than it should be — usually because the taxpayer never gathered the evidence.
When it arises
The situation requires three elements together:
- You are a Pakistani resident for the tax year, so worldwide income is generally within scope — the residence test.
- You have foreign-source income included in your Pakistani computation.
- Foreign tax has been paid on that same income in the source country.
Common cases: salary from a foreign employer where tax was withheld abroad, dividends or interest from foreign investments subject to withholding, rental income from property abroad, and business profits taxed in a country where you operate.
Credit, not deduction
| Step | Illustrative figure |
|---|---|
| Gross foreign income | Rs 3,000,000 |
| Foreign tax paid at 10% | Rs 300,000 |
| Included in Pakistani computation | Rs 3,000,000 — the gross figure |
| Pakistani tax attributable to that income | Computed on your overall position |
| Credit allowed | Lower of the foreign tax paid and the Pakistani tax attributable to that income |
You live and work outside Pakistan, you still hold property, bank accounts or rental income here, and nobody has ever told you in writing what your status actually is.
The cap, and what it means
The relief sits in section 103 of the Income Tax Ordinance 2001, which allows a resident a credit for foreign income tax paid on foreign-source income, capped at the Pakistan tax attributable to that same income. Two features of that wording do the work: it is a credit against Pakistan tax rather than a deduction from income, and the cap is computed on the foreign income alone rather than on the return as a whole.
The credit is generally limited to the Pakistani tax attributable to the foreign income. Two consequences follow:
- Where the foreign rate is lower than the Pakistani rate, you claim the full foreign tax and pay the difference in Pakistan. Total burden equals the Pakistani rate.
- Where the foreign rate is higher, the credit is capped at the Pakistani tax on that income and the excess is not recoverable from Pakistan. Total burden equals the foreign rate.
In effect you bear the higher of the two rates rather than the sum. That is relief rather than exemption, and it is worth understanding before assuming a foreign deduction cancels a Pakistani liability entirely.
The evidence, which is where claims fail
Assemble contemporaneously rather than at filing:
- The foreign tax return or assessment, showing the income and the tax charged.
- Withholding certificates from the foreign payer.
- Payment evidence that the tax was actually paid, not merely assessed or shown on a payslip.
- A statement from the foreign payer where withholding is the only mechanism.
- The exchange rate applied to convert both the income and the tax, on a consistent documented basis.
- Where relevant, a tax residence certificate and the treaty article relied on — treaties.
Why claims are refused
- No evidence of actual payment. A deduction shown on a payslip is not proof that tax was paid over.
- The foreign charge was not income tax. Social security and similar contributions are frequently outside the credit.
- Net income declared instead of gross, with the foreign tax treated as an expense.
- Mismatched income. The credit relates to tax on the same income; a claim that cannot be tied to a specific income stream is difficult to sustain.
- Inconsistent exchange rates between the income figure and the tax figure.
- The underlying income was never declared in the Pakistani return at all.
A worked credit computation
A Pakistani resident with Rs 4,000,000 of Pakistani salary and Rs 2,000,000 of foreign rental income, on which Rs 240,000 of foreign tax was paid at 12%:
| Step | Figure |
|---|---|
| Pakistani salary | Rs 4,000,000 |
| Foreign rental income, gross | Rs 2,000,000 |
| Foreign tax paid | Rs 240,000 |
| Foreign income included at gross, not net | Rs 2,000,000 |
| Pakistani tax attributable to the foreign income | Computed by reference to the proportion the foreign income bears to total income |
| Credit allowed | The lower of Rs 240,000 and that attributable Pakistani tax |
Note the attribution step. The credit is not simply the foreign tax against your total Pakistani liability — it is capped by the Pakistani tax on that particular income, which requires apportioning. Where you have several foreign income streams from different countries, the attribution generally has to be done stream by stream rather than in aggregate, so keep the income and the tax paired in your records from the outset.
The related obligation
Foreign income usually comes from foreign assets, and those have their own declaration position. A credit claim that references foreign employment or foreign investments while the corresponding assets are absent from the wealth statement is internally inconsistent — and information exchange between tax authorities makes foreign holdings increasingly visible independently. Handle both together: foreign assets and the reconciliation method.
Sources
This guide is written against the official and clearly labelled professional references below. Rates, thresholds and portal procedures change between reviews, so open the primary source before relying on a figure.
Questions people also ask
Can I deduct the foreign tax from my foreign income instead?
No, and the distinction matters. A credit reduces the Pakistani tax computed; a deduction would reduce the income on which it is computed. Treating foreign tax as an expense against foreign income understates your Pakistani liability and produces a computation that will not stand. Bring in the gross foreign income and claim the credit against the tax.
What if the foreign tax exceeds my Pakistani tax on that income?
The credit is generally capped at the Pakistani tax attributable to that foreign income, so the excess is not recoverable from Pakistan. That is the normal design of a credit system — Pakistan is relieving its own tax, not refunding another country revenue. Where the foreign rate is higher, you effectively bear the higher rate overall.
Do I need a treaty to claim a foreign tax credit?
Relief for foreign tax paid is available under the Ordinance in its own right, so a treaty is not always a precondition. A treaty may affect which country taxes what in the first place and may specify the relief method, so it matters — but the absence of a treaty does not automatically mean no relief. Establish the position on your facts.
What evidence do I need?
Evidence that the foreign tax was actually paid on that income — a foreign assessment or return, withholding certificates, payment receipts, and where relevant a statement from the foreign payer. A figure appearing on a payslip is a starting point rather than proof of payment. Obtain the evidence contemporaneously, because retrieving it from a foreign employer years later is difficult.
Can I claim credit for foreign social security contributions?
Not automatically. A credit is generally for foreign income tax on the same income, and social security or similar contributions are frequently not income tax for this purpose. Where a substantial part of your foreign deduction is a contribution rather than tax, establish the character of each element rather than claiming the total.
Send the tax year and the transaction or filing involved, and we will tell you what is actually required.
Talk to Chartered Advisory Open the tax calculators